Push, Pull and a Hand Shake: The Importance of Mix in Marketing

“We’ve got a killer website. I don’t understand why we aren’t doing well!”  If I had a nickel for every time I have heard that complaint . . . 

Most people going into business for the first time don’t understand that marketing and business development necessarily involve a mix of approaches. While the idea that one single silver bullet will hit the target is understandably appealing, it’s NOT going to work because the target is never one individual who always has the same feelings and needs.  Putting it that way makes obvious the need for multiple techniques and avenues to gain customer awareness and trust.

When I begin helping clients with their marketing plans, I always tell them that we need to plan for a mix of marketing techniques and investment. I use a mnemonic to help them remember the idea: Push, Pull and a Hand Shake.  They need to blend Push marketing techniques with Pull Marketing investment and use personal marketing—that Handshake—for outreach and message correction.

Push Marketing – the Virtual Tap on the Shoulder

When marketers talk about push marketing, they are referring to the wide variety of techniques that can be used to attract the attention of potential customers and motivate them to take the first step in doing business with their clients. Telemarketing, advertising, direct mail—all are examples of this type of “interrupt” activity designed to call attention to a business and responsive action from potential customers.

Although all of these techniques have their quirks: some are more effective for certain products and services than others. But as a rule of thumb, the more you spend, the greater your success: frequency plus good execution yields desired outcome.  Most of these techniques have the advantage of producing results fairly quickly.  

But marketing campaigns based solely on Push, or Interrupt, marketing techniques inevitably fail. Why? This year, the average consumer will see or hear 1 million marketing messages, almost 3,000 daily.  Since most automatically screen out most “interrupt messages,” other techniques must be used to get our attention. 

Pull Marketing Investment

Many marketing tools do not interrupt the customer but, rather, support his intention when he seeks a product or service. The best example is search marketing, which is enabled by a website or blog that, when searched by a search engine, leads your prospect to your online information. You can also pay a fee to have him directed to your online information (pay for click). The more information you put online, on your website, your blog, your social media outlets, the more likely you will be found by a prospect interested in your business. Creating this online footprint can be expensive, and you must shoulder some of the cost before you sell your first widget. 

Why assume the cost of implementing a Pull strategy? Simple: it works.  MediaPost recently reported that U.S. spending on search engine marketing (another pull marketing technique) will grow from $12.2 billion in 2008 to $22.4 billion in 2013.  Indeed, companies are embracing the idea of building entire campaigns around content that is shared through a variety of online and social media platforms. But just like efforts based solely on Push techniques, using Pull techniques in isolation may be self-limiting. For one thing, the expense of investing in and perpetually refreshing content in the absence of immediate demand (and business) is risky. Without continuing feedback from the target market in the form of measurable traffic, engagement, and commitment to the buying process, companies will be hard-pressed to continue to invest in Pull marketing. 

Pressing the Flesh

The least expensive and the most effective marketing technique is personal marketing. It  has long been employed by the smallest businesses. From the business card and referral swapping in networking groups to the attention-getting and positive reinforcement from public speaking events, actually meeting and touching your potential customers can be very gratifying. It provides a level of information and affirmation about you and your offerings that cannot be equaled.  A little time spent honing your 30-second commercial can garner you new business in a single afternoon of networking.  It also gives you immediate feedback about what parts of your message seem relevant and which parts don’t resonate with your prospects. You can also use that information to tweak your push and pull campaigns if they are running at the same time.

Marketing efforts that embody all three of these marketing modalities stand a good chance of being successful. They generate needed immediacy, higher conversion, and lower cost per lead.

SWOT Analysis -- A bit of James Bond for Your Business

“I need a four-letter word ending in ‘T,’” I yelled out to my wife in the next room. My daughter in Indiana had gotten me hooked on an i-Phone app called “Words with Friends,” and here I am at 6:30 a.m. squinting at the screen. 

“Try SWOT,” my wife yells, and, feeling particularly stupid, the palm of my hand flies up to hit my head. How could I not have thought of this word that I have used almost every week for the past years and written countless time?  In marketing business, SWOT has a special meaning because it’s an abbreviation for Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats. And for every small business, part of its annual planning process should be a SWOT analysis.

A SWOT analysis is a great way to identify and summarize many of the factors that can influence small business success. Along with goal setting and a marketing plan, it can help inform business owners and managers about their best choices for investment, hiring, promotion, and even new product development. 

I like to capture SWOT findings in a graphic consisting of a large rectangle divided into 4 equal squares. In the upper left goes a list of Strengths—the skills, abilities, and assets of the business. What does the business do particularly well? Are any employees “thought leaders” in their industry or can any employees be expected to make an extraordinary contribution to the business in the months ahead? Anything a customer wants that you provide and your competitor doesn't can constitute a possible strength.  This is the place to list every aspect of the business that makes it a “stand out” enterprise.

To the right of that rectangle goes Weaknesses, a list of problems, temporary or long term, which could impair success of the business in the months ahead. A cash-flow issue? Running out of space? No parking for customers? Lack the latest machine or offering? Rack your brains to think of anything that could hamper your business in the months ahead.  This is the place to list them.

In the bottom left square go those business bright spots that you see for the months ahead: Opportunities. If you provide house-cleaning services, find out how many potential customers are prospects moving into a new subdivision.  If you’re a printer, find out what businesses are changing their names—and consequently in the market for re-branded stationery products. Are your present customers converting to a new platform and will they need migration services? What upcoming opportunities do you see for an uptick in business or profits?

Finally, in the bottom right square--Threats. What stands between you and success? What specific development in the coming months could interfere with your plans for business success? Potential threats include downward price pressure, technology change, or even a specific competitor.  It is possible for opportunities to become threats and vice versa. But advance thought and planning can reduce your exposure to threats and, sometimes, even transform them into strengths.

For example, computer maker Dell has been locked in competition with HP for leadership in the PC market. Here is a SWOT analysis, compiled by a 3^rd party as an exercise, of the factors effecting Dell in the next year.

Once you’ve completed your SWOT analysis, you can use it to give your business an edge. Take all necessary steps to avoid the threats you’ve identified and leverage your strengths to position your business to take advantage of the opportunities you’ve identified.